Start with the people you already know
Your email list begins with people who have already shown interest in what you do — neighbors, friends, colleagues, past clients, or members of a group you lead. These are the easiest people to reach out to first because they already have a reason to hear from you.
Go through your phone contacts, past text threads, LinkedIn connections, and any spreadsheets or notebooks where you've written down names. If you've led a community group, taught a class, or managed a project, look for any roster or sign-in sheet. The goal is not to contact everyone you've ever met, but to identify people who might actually want to receive messages from you about the topic at hand.
Write a short, honest message explaining what you're building and why you're reaching out. For example: "I'm starting a neighborhood safety group and want to send updates to people who've expressed interest. Would you like to be on the list?" This gives people a clear choice and a reason to say yes.
Key Takeaways
- Your first subscribers should be people who already know you or have shown interest in your topic, not strangers you've purchased or scraped from the internet.
- A straightforward sign-up form on a website, printed sign-up sheet at an event, or direct message asking permission is enough to start collecting addresses legally.
- Keep your first message clear about what people are signing up for and how often they'll hear from you.
- Store email addresses in a spreadsheet or free email service (Gmail, Outlook) until your list grows large enough to need a dedicated tool.
- Never add someone to your list without their permission, and always include a way for them to unsubscribe or stop receiving messages.
Collect addresses through a straightforward sign-up method
You don't need fancy software to start. A printed sign-up sheet at a community meeting, a Google Form linked in a text or email, or a straightforward question ("Can I add you to my email list?") works perfectly fine for your first 50 to 100 people.
If you have a website or social media account, add a line that says something like "Get updates by email" with a link to a Google Form. Google Forms is free, collects responses in a spreadsheet, and requires no technical knowledge. You can create one in five minutes and share the link anywhere — in a Facebook post, on a neighborhood app, in an email signature, or printed on a flyer.
The form should ask for a first name and email address at minimum. You can ask for a neighborhood, street, or interest area if that helps you organize later, but keep it short. The longer the form, the fewer people will complete it.
Store addresses safely while your list is small
For your first few hundred subscribers, a Google Sheet or Excel spreadsheet is sufficient. Create columns for first name, email address, date added, and any other detail that matters to you (neighborhood, interests, how they found you). This takes two minutes to set up and costs nothing.
Keep this file on your personal computer or in Google Drive, and do not share the link publicly. If you're working with a co-organizer or group, you can share the spreadsheet with them using Google Drive's sharing settings — give them "editor" access so they can add names too.
As your list grows beyond 500 or 1,000 people, you'll want to move to an email service that handles sending to many people at once. Free options include Mailchimp, Brevo (formerly Sendinblue), and ConvertKit's free tier. These services store your list, let you write one message and send it to everyone at once, and automatically handle unsubscribe requests. But you don't need them yet.
Make it clear what people are signing up for
When someone gives you their email address, they need to know what they're agreeing to receive. Write a one-sentence description: "Weekly neighborhood safety tips," "Monthly community garden updates," "Homeowner association meeting notices," or "Local real estate market reports." Be specific about the topic and how often you'll send messages.
Include this description on your sign-up form, in any message asking for permission, and in your first email to new subscribers. If you plan to send weekly messages but then send daily ones instead, people will unsubscribe or mark you as spam. If you say monthly and send weekly, the same thing happens. Honesty about frequency keeps people engaged and prevents your messages from being filtered.
Send a welcome message to confirm the address works
The moment someone signs up, send them a short email that confirms their address is correct and reminds them what they've joined. This email should include your name, what they'll receive, how often, and a link or instructions for unsubscribing if they change their mind.
Example: "Hi Sarah, thanks for signing up for neighborhood safety updates. You'll hear from me twice a month with tips and local news. If you want to unsubscribe at any time, reply to this email or click the link at the bottom. Looking forward to staying in touch."
This welcome message serves two purposes: it confirms the email address is real and active, and it gives new subscribers a chance to unsubscribe when ready if they signed up by mistake or changed their mind. It also sets the tone for what they can expect.
Grow your list by asking in places where interested people already gather
Don't buy email lists or scrape addresses from websites. Instead, ask for sign-ups in places where people who care about your topic are already spending time. If you're building a list about homeownership, ask at a local real estate office, a home improvement store, a community center, or a neighborhood Facebook group. If it's about gardening, ask at a farmers market or garden club.
Put a printed sign-up sheet at events you attend or organize. Include a QR code that links to your Google Form so people can sign up with their phone on the spot. Mention the list in your email signature, in your social media bio, and in any newsletter or message you already send out.
Ask existing subscribers to share the sign-up link with friends who might be interested. A personal recommendation ("My neighbor sends great tips about home maintenance, you should join") is far more effective than a random ad, and it brings in people who are more likely to stay engaged.
Never buy, scrape, or add addresses without permission
Sending unsolicited email is not only ineffective — it's illegal in most places. The CAN-SPAM Act in the United States, GDPR in Europe, and similar laws in other countries require that you have permission before sending marketing or informational emails to someone. "Permission" means they actively chose to receive messages from you, not that you found their address somewhere.
If you buy a list of email addresses from a vendor, send emails to addresses you scraped from a website, or add someone without their consent, your messages will be marked as spam, your email account may be suspended, and you could face legal consequences. It's not worth it, and it doesn't work anyway — people who didn't ask to hear from you delete your messages.
Start small with people who want to hear from you. A list of 50 engaged subscribers who read your messages is worth far more than a list of 5,000 people who delete them unread.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use Gmail to send messages to my whole list at once?
Gmail's "Bcc" field lets you send one message to many people, but it's slow and error-prone for lists larger than 20 or 30 people. For anything bigger, use a free email service like Mailchimp or Brevo, which are designed for this and handle unsubscribe requests automatically. Gmail also has limits on how many emails you can send per day, so a dedicated service is safer.
What should I do if someone asks to be removed from my list?
Remove them when ready. Include an unsubscribe option in every message you send — usually a line at the bottom saying "Reply to this email to unsubscribe" or a link they can click. Honor unsubscribe requests within 24 hours. This is both legal requirement and basic respect.
Is it okay to add someone's email if they gave it to me for a different reason?
No. If someone gave you their email to sign up for a one-time event or to receive a specific document, don't add them to a recurring mailing list without asking first. Send them a message saying "I'm starting an email list about [topic]. Would you like to be added?" and wait for them to say yes.
How do I know if my list is growing at a healthy pace?
There's no universal "healthy" growth rate — it depends on your topic, your network, and how actively you're promoting the list. Early on, focus on getting 20 to 50 engaged subscribers rather than 500 disengaged ones. Once you have that core group, growth usually accelerates as people share the list with others.
What's the best time to send emails to my list?
Tuesday through Thursday mornings, between 9 a.m. and noon, tend to have higher open rates, but the best time is whenever your specific subscribers are likely to read. If your list is mostly working parents, early morning or evening might work better. If it's retirees, midday might be ideal. Start with one time and pay attention to which messages get opened — that tells you what works for your audience.