Healthfirst customer service phone numbers by plan type
Healthfirst operates separate phone lines depending on which plan you have. The main customer service number for most Healthfirst members is 1-888-343-3547, available Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern time. If you have a Medicaid plan through Healthfirst, you may reach a different line than someone with a Medicare Advantage plan, so having your member ID card handy before you call will help the representative route you correctly.
For Medicare Advantage members specifically, Healthfirst maintains a dedicated line at 1-877-711-4721, also available during standard business hours. If you are calling about a Medicaid managed care plan, the number 1-888-343-3547 typically handles those inquiries. Healthfirst also serves members in New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, and the same numbers work across all three states.
Before calling, locate your member ID card. The representative will ask for this number to pull up your account. If you cannot find your card, you can still call — the representative can look up your information using your name and date of birth, though it may take slightly longer.
Key Takeaways
- The main Healthfirst customer service number is 1-888-343-3547 for most members, and 1-877-711-4721 for Medicare Advantage members.
- Both lines are open Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern time, and do not operate on weekends or federal holidays.
- Having your member ID card ready before calling will help the representative locate your account faster.
- Healthfirst serves members in New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, and the same phone numbers work in all three states.
What you can handle by phone
Healthfirst customer service representatives can answer questions about your coverage, help you understand your benefits, and explain how to use your plan. You can call to ask about copayments, deductibles, whether a specific service is covered under your plan, and how to find an in-network provider. Representatives can also help if you need to update your contact information or address on file.
If you need to report a claim issue, dispute a bill, or ask about the status of a claim you submitted, the phone line is the right place to start. The representative can often resolve straightforward billing questions on the spot or direct you to the department that handles your specific issue. For authorization or prior approval questions — whether your doctor needs permission from Healthfirst before a procedure — calling is usually faster than waiting for a written response.
When the phone line may not be the best option
If you need to submit new documents — such as proof of income for a Medicaid plan or updated insurance information — the phone representative will typically direct you to mail, fax, or upload them through the Healthfirst website instead. Calling can start the process, but the actual document submission usually happens through one of those other channels.
For urgent medical questions or emergencies, do not call Healthfirst customer service. Call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room if you are experiencing a medical emergency. If you need to reach your doctor after hours, use the nurse line or on-call service through your doctor's office, not Healthfirst.
Reaching Healthfirst outside standard business hours
Healthfirst customer service lines do not operate on weekends or federal holidays. If you need to reach someone outside Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. Eastern time, you have limited options through the phone line itself. However, many account questions can be handled through the Healthfirst website or mobile app, which are available 24 hours a day.
If you have an urgent issue that cannot wait until the next business day, check your member ID card or the back of your insurance card — it may list a separate urgent care line or nurse hotline. Some Healthfirst plans include a nurse information line that operates outside standard customer service hours.
Using the Healthfirst website instead of calling
The Healthfirst website allows you to view your claims, check your coverage details, find in-network providers, and update some account information without calling. You can log in at www.healthfirst.org using your member ID and password. If you do not have a password set up, you can create one on the login page.
The website also has a live chat feature during business hours, which may be faster than waiting on hold. You can access this through your account dashboard after logging in. For questions that do not require when ready answers, you can also submit a message through your account and expect a response within one to two business days.
Preparing for your call
Before you dial, write down the specific questions you want to ask. Have your member ID card, any relevant medical records or claim numbers, and a pen and paper ready to take notes. If you are calling about a specific claim or bill, have that document in front of you so you can reference dates and amounts.
If you are calling on behalf of someone else — such as a parent or spouse — be prepared to provide proof of authorization. Healthfirst cannot discuss account details with someone other than the member without written permission on file, though you can still call to ask general questions about how the plan works.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Healthfirst have a phone line for billing questions?
Billing questions go through the main customer service number, 1-888-343-3547. The representative can look up your account and explain charges, discuss payment options, or direct you to the billing department if your issue needs specialized handling. Have your member ID and the bill or claim in question ready when you call.
Can I reach Healthfirst by phone on Saturday or Sunday?
No, customer service phone lines are closed on weekends and federal holidays. You can use the website or mobile app 24 hours a day, or wait until the next business day to call. If you have an urgent medical question, contact your doctor's office or a nurse hotline instead.
What if I am calling from outside New York, New Jersey, or Connecticut?
Healthfirst primarily serves members in those three states. If you live elsewhere and have a Healthfirst plan, call the main number on your member ID card — it may be different from the standard lines listed here. Your card will have the correct contact information for your specific plan.
Do I need to pay to call Healthfirst?
No, the phone numbers listed are toll-free. You will not be charged for calling, though standard phone rates may explore if you are calling from a mobile phone. The call may take 10 to 20 minutes depending on how busy the line is, so plan accordingly.
What should I do if I cannot understand the representative?
You can ask the representative to speak more slowly or to repeat information. You can also ask for a callback at a time that works better for you, or request that information be sent to you in writing. If you need language support, let the representative know — Healthfirst offers interpretation services in multiple languages.