FirstKey Homes contact information and what to expect when you call

FirstKey Homes is a property management company that handles rental housing across multiple states. If you rent from FirstKey or need to reach them about a property, you will call their customer service line. The main phone number is 833-435-7394. This line handles tenant inquiries, maintenance requests, rent payments, and lease questions.

When you call, have your lease number or property address ready. FirstKey's phone system routes calls based on your reason for contacting them, so you may be asked to select from a menu before speaking to someone. Wait times vary by time of day and season — calling early in the morning or mid-week typically means shorter holds than calling on Fridays or near rent due dates.

FirstKey also operates regional offices in different states where they manage properties. If you need to speak with someone at a specific location, you can ask the main line to transfer you, or you can search online for the regional office nearest to your property.

Key Takeaways

  • The main FirstKey Homes customer service number is 833-435-7394 and handles maintenance, rent payment, and lease questions.
  • Have your lease number or property address available before calling to speed up routing to the right department.
  • FirstKey operates regional offices in multiple states, and you can request transfer to a local office if needed.
  • Maintenance emergencies may have a separate after-hours line — ask when you call during business hours what number to use at night or on weekends.
  • You can also check your lease or any welcome materials from FirstKey for additional contact numbers specific to your property or region.

What to have ready before you call

Gathering information before you dial saves time on hold and helps the representative find your account faster. Write down your lease number if you have it — this is usually on the first page of your lease agreement or on any rent payment statements FirstKey has sent you. If you do not have the lease number, your full name and the property address work just as well.

If you are calling about a maintenance problem, describe what is broken or not working and when you first noticed it. If you are calling about a rent payment, know whether you are asking about a past-due amount, setting up a payment plan, or reporting that you already sent a payment. If you are calling about your lease — to ask about renewal, early termination, or a lease term question — have the specific section or clause number if you can find it.

Calling about maintenance and repairs

FirstKey handles maintenance requests through their customer service line. When you call 833-435-7394 and select the maintenance option, describe the problem clearly: whether it is a leak, broken appliance, heating or cooling issue, plumbing, electrical, or structural damage. Tell them how long the problem has existed and whether it affects your ability to live safely in the unit.

Emergency repairs — such as no heat in winter, no water, gas smell, or active leaks — may may have access to for same-day or next-day service. Non-emergency repairs like a broken cabinet or slow drain typically take longer to schedule. When you call, ask for an estimated timeframe so you know when to expect someone. FirstKey will either send their own maintenance team or contract with a local vendor depending on the type of repair and your location.

Calling about rent payments and account questions

If you need to make a rent payment, ask the representative for the payment methods FirstKey accepts — this may include online payment through their portal, automatic bank transfer, check by mail, or credit card (though credit card payments often carry a fee). They can also tell you the exact due date for your lease and whether FirstKey charges late fees if rent arrives after that date.

If you are behind on rent or facing a hardship, tell FirstKey during the call. Some property managers work with tenants on payment plans or can direct you to local rental information programs. Having this conversation early — before an eviction notice is filed — gives you more options. FirstKey will document what you discuss, and you should ask for a confirmation email or letter summarizing any agreement you reach.

Regional offices and after-hours contact

FirstKey Homes operates in multiple states including Texas, Georgia, Florida, and others. If the main line does not resolve your issue or you prefer to work with a local office, ask to be transferred or request the phone number for the regional office handling your property. Some regions have dedicated lines for specific services like leasing or maintenance.

For emergencies outside business hours — such as a burst pipe at midnight or no heat on a Sunday — ask during your daytime call what number to use. Many property managers have an after-hours emergency line separate from the main customer service number. Write down that number and keep it with your lease so you have it when you need it.

What to do if you cannot reach FirstKey by phone

If the phone line is consistently busy or you prefer not to call, FirstKey may have an online tenant portal where you can submit maintenance requests, make payments, and view your account. Check any welcome packet or emails FirstKey sent when you signed your lease for a link to this portal and instructions for logging in.

You can also send a written request by mail to FirstKey's regional office — the address should be on your lease or on any payment coupons they provided. Written requests create a paper trail, which can be useful if a maintenance issue is not addressed or if you need to document that you reported a problem. Keep a copy of anything you mail.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is FirstKey Homes' main phone number?

The main customer service line is 833-435-7394. This number handles maintenance requests, rent payments, lease questions, and general tenant inquiries. Have your lease number or property address ready when you call.

Do I need to pay a fee to call FirstKey?

No. Calling 833-435-7394 is a standard phone call and costs whatever your phone plan charges for calls. FirstKey does not charge a fee for customer service calls. However, if you pay rent by credit card through their system, FirstKey or their payment processor may charge a convenience fee.

What if I have an emergency repair at night or on a weekend?

Call the main line during business hours and ask for the after-hours emergency number. FirstKey typically has a separate line for emergencies like no heat, no water, gas leaks, or active flooding. Write down that number and keep it accessible.

Can I reach FirstKey through email or online chat?

FirstKey's primary contact method is phone, but they may offer an online tenant portal for submitting maintenance requests and viewing your account. Check your lease documents or welcome materials for a portal link. Some regional offices may also respond to emails, though phone is usually faster.

What if FirstKey is not responding to my maintenance request?

Call back and ask to speak with a supervisor or manager. Document the date and time of your first call and the name of anyone you spoke with. If FirstKey continues to ignore a serious repair — such as a heating problem in winter — you may have legal rights to withhold rent or repair-and-deduct depending on your state's tenant laws. Contact your local housing authority or tenant rights organization for guidance.