The games Reddit players recommend most for story and world building
If you ask Reddit's gaming communities which action RPGs have the strongest stories and worlds, three names come up repeatedly: Baldur's Gate 3, Elden Ring, and The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Each one builds its world differently, and which one appeals to you depends on what kind of storytelling you want — dialogue-heavy narrative, environmental storytelling, or a mix of both.
Baldur's Gate 3 is praised most often for branching dialogue and character depth. The game lets your choices reshape conversations and outcomes in ways that feel meaningful rather than cosmetic. Elden Ring takes the opposite approach: it scatters story fragments across item descriptions, NPC dialogue you can easily miss, and environmental details, letting you piece together the world's history yourself. The Witcher 3 sits between them, with a strong main narrative and side quests that often feel like short stories in their own right.
What matters most is your own preference. Some players love being told a story directly. Others prefer discovering it. Your device's power also matters — these games have different performance needs, which we covered in the Getting Started section.
Key Takeaways
- Baldur's Gate 3 offers the most dialogue choices and character-driven storytelling, with decisions that reshape conversations and outcomes throughout the game.
- Elden Ring builds its world through environmental details and item descriptions rather than cutscenes, rewarding players who explore and piece together lore themselves.
- The Witcher 3 combines a strong main story with side quests that function as self-contained narratives, plus a world that feels lived-in and reactive to your choices.
- Story preference varies by player — some want narrative handed to them, others want to discover it — so reading what each game emphasizes helps you pick the right fit.
- All three games run differently depending on your device, so check the performance requirements before you buy.
Baldur's Gate 3: Dialogue and character relationships as the core story
Baldur's Gate 3 is built around conversation. Nearly every major story beat happens through dialogue trees where your choices matter. You can persuade, intimidate, deceive, or charm your way through situations, and the game remembers what you said. Characters respond differently to you based on past conversations, and relationships develop or fracture based on your decisions.
The world itself — the Forgotten Realms setting from Dungeons & Dragons — is detailed but secondary to the characters. You meet a cleric, a rogue, a wizard, and a warlock, and the story becomes as much about their personal quests and conflicts as it is about the main plot. Reddit players often say they replay the game to see how different dialogue choices change which characters trust you or what endings become available.
The trade-off is that Baldur's Gate 3 requires reading. There is no voice acting for your character, and many story details come through text. If you prefer games that show you the story through action and environment rather than conversation, this may feel slow.
Elden Ring: A world you piece together from fragments
Elden Ring tells its story backwards and sideways. You will not find a clear narrative arc in cutscenes. Instead, the world's history is hidden in item descriptions, NPC dialogue that is straightforward to miss, environmental details, and lore that players have spent months decoding together on Reddit and other forums.
This approach appeals to players who like mystery and discovery. You might pick up a sword and read its description, which mentions a war from centuries ago. You meet an NPC who hints at that same war. You find a location that looks like a battlefield. Slowly, a picture emerges. The world feels ancient and layered because you are uncovering it rather than being told about it.
The downside is that you can miss huge parts of the story entirely. Some NPCs have questlines that are straightforward to lock yourself out of. If you do not talk to the right person at the right time, their story ends and you will not know what happened. Many players use community wikis and guides to catch what they would otherwise miss, which changes the experience from discovery to archaeology.
The Witcher 3: A strong main story plus side quests that matter
The Witcher 3 gives you a clear main narrative — you are looking for someone, and that search takes you across a detailed world — while filling that world with side quests that often feel like their own complete stories. A contract to hunt a monster might uncover a family tragedy. A seemingly straightforward task might reveal political corruption.
The world reacts to your choices. People remember what you did in previous quests. Locations change based on your decisions. The game feels like it is responding to you rather than following a fixed path, even though the main story is more linear than Baldur's Gate 3.
The story is told through cutscenes, dialogue, and exploration. You do not have to piece together lore from item descriptions the way you do in Elden Ring, but you also have fewer dialogue choices that reshape the narrative. The Witcher 3 is a middle ground: strong storytelling without the branching complexity of Baldur's Gate 3, and a clearer narrative than Elden Ring.
How to decide which story style fits you
Ask yourself what kind of story experience you want. If you like making choices that change how characters see you and what options become available, Baldur's Gate 3 is the strongest choice. If you like exploring a mysterious world and piecing together its history yourself, Elden Ring rewards that approach. If you want a strong main story that does not require you to decode lore or make constant dialogue choices, The Witcher 3 is more straightforward.
Also consider how much time you want to spend. Baldur's Gate 3 is longest if you read all dialogue and explore all character relationships. Elden Ring can be shorter if you ignore lore entirely, or much longer if you hunt down every NPC questline. The Witcher 3 is somewhere in the middle, with a main story that takes 50 to 100 hours depending on how many side quests you do.
Your device matters too. Baldur's Gate 3 is demanding and runs best on newer hardware. Elden Ring and The Witcher 3 have more flexible performance options. Check the requirements for your specific device before you buy.
What Reddit players say about other story-focused action RPGs
Beyond the top three, Reddit mentions several other games worth knowing about. Dragon's Dogma 2 has a world that changes based on your choices, with NPCs who can die permanently and whose deaths reshape the story. Cyberpunk 2077 has strong character writing and multiple story paths depending on which faction you align with, though the main narrative is less flexible than Baldur's Gate 3. Kingdom Come: Deliverance builds its world through historical detail and NPC routines rather than fantasy lore, making it feel grounded in a way other action RPGs do not.
These games are less frequently recommended than the top three, usually because they have narrower appeal or more technical issues. But if none of the first three match what you are looking for, these are worth researching on Reddit's gaming communities, where players discuss specific story moments and world details.
How to find more detailed discussion on Reddit
Reddit's main gaming communities — r/gaming, r/Games, and r/JRPG (which covers action RPGs too) — have ongoing discussions about story and world building. Game-specific subreddits like r/Eldenring, r/BaldursGate3, and r/witcher have players who can answer specific questions about story depth and lore.
When you search, look for threads asking "best story" or "best world building" rather than "best game overall." Story preference is personal, and a thread focused on narrative will give you better information than a general ranking. You can also search for comparisons — "Baldur's Gate 3 vs Elden Ring story" will show you discussions where players explain the differences directly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need to play previous games in a series to understand the story?
No for Baldur's Gate 3 or Elden Ring — both are designed for new players. The Witcher 3 references the previous games and books, but you can understand the main story without that background. You will miss some character context, but the game explains enough for you to follow along.
Which game has the least confusing story?
The Witcher 3 tells its story most directly. Baldur's Gate 3 requires you to pay attention to dialogue but is clear about what is happening. Elden Ring is the hardest to follow because so much lore is optional and hidden.
Can I skip the story and just play for combat?
Yes in all three, but you will get less out of them. Baldur's Gate 3 is most story-focused — skipping dialogue means missing most of the game. Elden Ring lets you ignore lore entirely and just fight. The Witcher 3 has good combat but is designed around its narrative.
Which game's world is biggest?
The Witcher 3 has the largest explorable map. Elden Ring is smaller but denser with secrets. Baldur's Gate 3 is the smallest but most detailed in terms of how NPCs and locations respond to your choices.
Do these games have different story endings?
Baldur's Gate 3 has multiple endings that change based on your choices throughout the game. The Witcher 3 has a few different endings depending on key decisions. Elden Ring has multiple endings but they are more about which ending you trigger than how you played.