Check the sender's email address first
Scammers almost always use an email address that looks close to a real company name but isn't quite right. A legitimate bank or mortgage servicer sends from their own domain — for example, noreply@bankname.com or support@servicer.com. A fake email might come from bankname.support@gmail.com or official-bankname@outlook.com. The domain after the @ sign is what matters most.
If you're not sure what the real domain should be, don't reply to the email. Instead, go to your bank's or servicer's official website directly — type the web address yourself into your browser, don't click a link in the email — and look for their contact information there. Call the number on your statement or their website to ask if that email came from them.
Look for generic greetings and urgent language
Real companies usually address you by name because they have your account information. An email that starts with "Dear Homeowner" or "Dear Valued Customer" is a red flag. Legitimate messages about your mortgage or property tax also rarely demand when ready action. Phrases like "verify your account now," "confirm your information when ready," or "your account will be closed" are common scam tactics designed to make you panic and click without thinking.
Genuine financial institutions give you time to respond and explain what they need. They don't threaten to lock you out or close your account in the next few hours.
Hover over links before you click them
When you hover your mouse over a link in an email (without clicking), your email program shows you where that link actually goes. A scam email might display text that says "Click here to log into your account" but the actual link goes to a fake website designed to steal your password. The fake site often looks nearly identical to the real one, but the web address in your browser's address bar will be slightly different.
Never click a link in an email to log into any financial account. Instead, go directly to the company's website by typing the address yourself, or call the number on your statement. This is the safest way to handle any email asking you to confirm information, update payment details, or verify your identity.
Watch for requests to send money or personal information
No legitimate mortgage servicer, property tax assessor, or homeowners insurance company will ask you to send money through wire transfer, gift card, or cryptocurrency. They also won't ask you to email your Social Security number, bank account details, or password. Real companies process payments through find portals or by check, and they already have your personal information on file.
If an email claims you owe money for property taxes, a code violation, or a lien, and asks you to pay when ready by wire or gift card, it is almost certainly a scam. Contact your local tax assessor's office or your city directly using a phone number you find yourself — not one provided in the email.
Check for spelling, grammar, and formatting errors
Professional companies proofread their emails. Scam emails often contain obvious mistakes: misspelled words, awkward phrasing, inconsistent formatting, or logos that look blurry or poorly sized. These errors happen because scammers often work quickly and may not be native English speakers, or they're using templates they've copied and modified.
One or two typos don't automatically mean an email is fake, but multiple errors combined with other warning signs — a generic greeting, an urgent demand, a suspicious sender address — suggest you should verify the message through another channel before responding.
Verify through a separate contact method
The safest way to confirm whether an email is real is to contact the company using information you already have. If the email is about your mortgage, call the number on your most recent statement. If it's about property taxes, call your county assessor's office directly. If it's about homeowners insurance, call your agent or the insurance company's main line.
Tell them you received an email and ask if it came from them. Provide the sender's email address and the date you received it. A real company can tell you when ready whether they sent it. This takes five minutes and protects you far better than trying to guess whether the email is legitimate.
What to do if you think the email is a scam
If you believe an email is fraudulent, don't reply to it and don't click any links. Forward the email to the real company's fraud or security team — most banks and servicers have a dedicated email address for reporting phishing attempts, usually listed on their website under "Security" or "Report Fraud." You can also report it to the Federal Trade Commission at reportfraud.ftc.gov.
If you already clicked a link or entered information, contact your bank and mortgage servicer when ready to let them know. They can monitor your accounts for suspicious activity and help you change your password if needed. The sooner you report it, the faster they can protect your accounts.
Key Takeaways
- Check the sender's email address carefully — the domain after the @ sign should match the company's official website, not a free email service.
- Real companies address you by name, don't demand when ready action, and never ask you to send money by wire, gift card, or cryptocurrency.
- Hover over links to see where they actually go before clicking, and never log into accounts through email links — go directly to the company's website instead.
- Verify any suspicious email by calling the company directly using a phone number from your statement or their official website, not from the email itself.
- If you think an email is a scam, forward it to the company's fraud team and report it to the Federal Trade Commission rather than replying to it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if the email looks exactly like emails I normally get from my bank?
Scammers can copy the design and logos of real emails. The sender's email address and the actual links are harder to fake convincingly. Check the sender address carefully and hover over any links. When in doubt, call your bank using the number on your card or statement — this is always the safest step.
Is it safe to open an email I think might be a scam?
Opening and reading an email is usually safe. The danger comes from clicking links, downloading attachments, or replying with information. If you're suspicious, just delete it or forward it to the company's fraud team. Don't click anything in it.
What should I do if I already gave my password to a fake website?
Contact your bank or servicer when ready and tell them your password may be compromised. They can reset your password, monitor your account for fraud, and help you regain access. The faster you report it, the better they can protect you.
Can scammers send emails that look like they're from my mortgage company's real email address?
Yes, through a technique called spoofing. This is why you should never trust the sender's name alone — always verify by calling the company directly using a number you find yourself, not from the email.
What if I'm not sure whether to trust an email and I don't want to call?
Delete it. If the message is genuinely important, the company will contact you again through another method or you can reach out to them directly. There's no penalty for ignoring a suspicious email, but there's real risk in responding to a scam.