Why your second monitor shows up in screenshots
When you take a screenshot on Windows or Mac, the operating system captures everything visible across all connected monitors by default. If you have a second screen plugged in, it will appear in the screenshot unless you tell the system to capture only your primary display. This happens whether your second monitor is in use or sitting idle.
The reason this matters: if you're sharing a screenshot for work, tech support, or online, a second monitor in the image can expose personal information, passwords in other windows, or details you didn't intend to share. Disabling the second screen from screenshots means you control exactly what appears in the image you send out.
Key Takeaways
- Windows and Mac both capture all monitors by default, but you can change this in settings to capture only your primary display.
- The simplest method on both systems is to use the built-in screenshot tool and select the specific area or window you want, rather than capturing the whole screen.
- If you need full-screen captures without the second monitor, you can disable the second display temporarily in your display settings, take the screenshot, then re-enable it.
- Third-party screenshot tools like Snagit or ShareX let you choose which monitor to capture before you take the shot.
Capturing only your primary monitor on Windows
The fastest way to exclude your second monitor is to use the Windows Snipping Tool or Screenshot tool and select only the area you need. Open the Snipping Tool (search for it in the Start menu), click New, then drag to select only the portion of your primary monitor you want to capture. This method works regardless of how many monitors you have connected.
If you need to capture your entire primary monitor without the second one appearing, you have two options. First, you can temporarily disable the second display: right-click on your desktop, select Display settings, scroll down to the Multiple displays section, click on your second monitor, and select Disconnect this display from the dropdown. Take your screenshot, then go back to Display settings and select Extend or Duplicate to turn the second monitor back on.
The second option is to use a third-party tool. Snagit and ShareX both let you choose which monitor to capture before taking the screenshot. These tools show you a preview of each monitor and let you click the one you want to capture.
Capturing only your primary monitor on Mac
On Mac, the built-in screenshot tool (Command + Shift + 4 or Command + Shift + 5) captures all visible monitors. The easiest way to exclude your second display is to select only the area you want: press Command + Shift + 5, then drag to select just the portion of your primary monitor. This avoids capturing the second screen entirely.
If you need a full-screen capture of only your primary monitor, you can temporarily disable the second display. Go to System Settings (or System Preferences on older macOS versions), click Displays, select your second monitor from the sidebar, and click Disconnect. Take your screenshot, then return to Displays and click Reconnect to turn it back on.
Alternatively, use a third-party tool like Snagit or CleanMyMac's screenshot feature, which both allow you to select which monitor to capture from a menu before taking the shot.
Using the selection method for any screenshot
The most reliable way to exclude your second monitor from any screenshot is to avoid capturing the full screen in the first place. Instead of pressing Print Screen or using a full-screen capture command, use your system's selection tool to draw a box around only what you need on your primary monitor.
On Windows, use Snipping Tool or press Windows Key + Shift + S to open the screenshot menu, then select Rectangle and drag to select your area. On Mac, press Command + Shift + 5, then click and drag to select. Both methods let you see exactly what will be captured before you take the shot, and neither will include your second monitor if you don't drag into that area.
This approach also has a side benefit: your screenshots are smaller files and show only the relevant content, making them clearer to share or store.
Temporarily disabling your second monitor
If you need to take multiple full-screen screenshots without your second monitor appearing, disabling it temporarily is faster than selecting each time. The process takes about 30 seconds and doesn't require restarting.
On Windows: Right-click the desktop, select Display settings, scroll to Multiple displays, click your second monitor in the list, and choose Disconnect this display from the dropdown menu. Take your screenshots. Then return to Display settings, click the second monitor again, and select Extend (to use it as a second screen) or Duplicate (to mirror your primary display). Your monitor will reconnect without requiring a restart.
On Mac: Go to System Settings or System Preferences, click Displays, select your second monitor from the sidebar, and click Disconnect. Take your screenshots. Return to Displays, select the second monitor again, and click Reconnect. The display will turn back on when ready.
Third-party screenshot tools that let you choose monitors
If you take screenshots regularly and want the most control, a dedicated screenshot tool saves time. Snagit (available for Windows and Mac) shows you all connected monitors in a menu and lets you click the one you want to capture. ShareX (Windows only) offers the same feature for free. Both tools let you select a monitor, a window, or a custom area before capturing.
These tools also offer features like automatic scrolling capture (useful for long web pages), built-in editing, and cloud storage integration. If you're already using one of these tools for other reasons, using it for screenshots ensures your second monitor never appears unless you want it to.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will disabling my second monitor affect my work if I'm using it?
Yes — any windows or programs running on your second monitor will be hidden while it's disabled. If you need to keep working on both monitors, use the selection method instead of disabling the display. You can draw a selection box around only your primary monitor without touching the second one.
Can I set Windows to always capture only my primary monitor?
Windows doesn't have a system-wide setting for this, but you can change the default behavior in individual apps. In Microsoft Edge or Chrome, you can set screenshot extensions to default to a specific monitor. For most other uses, the selection tool (Windows Key + Shift + S) is the fastest option.
Does this work if my second monitor is wireless?
Yes, the same methods work for wireless monitors, USB-C displays, or any other type of secondary display. Disabling and re-enabling works the same way in Display settings regardless of how the monitor connects.
What if I want to capture both monitors but in separate screenshots?
Take one screenshot of your primary monitor using the selection method, then disable the second monitor, take another screenshot, and re-enable it. Alternatively, use a third-party tool that lets you select which monitor to capture, then run it twice — once for each display.